2 Giant Goofballs: A NY Giants Podcast

The Giants ended the Odell Beckham Jr. reunion after only three games, but moving on from OBJ does nothing to solve their bigger problem: this offense has now gone two straight games without scoring a touchdown.
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
Can the Giants offense finally finish drives against Arizona? 
his matchup gives Jameis Winston and the offense a real opportunity, but after two straight weeks of settling for field goals, simply moving the ball is no longer enough.
Drew and Rob start with a Giants roster that barely resembles the one we were discussing a week ago. Jihad Ward is back after being signed away from Minnesota’s practice squad, giving the defense a familiar veteran while Brian Burns is gone. The Joey Porter Jr. trade rumors continue getting louder, but there is still a major gap between legitimate interest and an actual deal being close.
J.J. McCarthy also went through his first Giants practice while Winston continued receiving the first-team work. That discussion turns into the growing question about some of Winston’s throws coming up short and whether it is simply execution, timing or something worth monitoring.
Then comes OBJ.
Beckham’s second Giants stint ends after one regular-season target and zero catches. The Giants never found a meaningful offensive role for him, and Harbaugh acknowledged they simply were not getting enough from that roster spot. We debate whether the signing was a mistake from the beginning, whether Beckham deserved an actual opportunity before being released, and why special-teams value ultimately helped squeeze him off the roster.
The second half turns to Giants-Cardinals. New York is 2-1, tied atop the NFC East and facing an Arizona defense that has allowed offenses to create explosive plays. Winston needs to reconnect with Isaiah Likely, Malik Nabers has to be a major part of the plan, and the Giants cannot allow field goals to become their offensive identity.
Defensively, Jeremiyah Love’s growing workload presents another test for a run defense that has already been exposed once this season. Trey McBride gives Jacoby Brissett an easy underneath target, while Michael Wilson and Marvin Harrison Jr. create different problems outside.
And without Brian Burns, the pressure falls on Abdul Carter, Kayvon Thibodeaux, Jihad Ward and Dennard Wilson to figure out how to affect a quarterback who wants the ball out quickly.
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The Giants gained a 23-year-old former top-10 quarterback, but they sacrificed a 2027 fifth-round pick for a player Minnesota had already pushed to QB3. Drew and Rob debate whether J.J. McCarthy represents cheap developmental upside or whether the Vikings moving on this quickly should be a major warning sign.
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
Why did the Giants trade for J.J. McCarthy? 
New York is betting that McCarthy's age, pedigree and developmental upside are worth the draft pick as the Giants deal with Jaxson Dart's injury. But Minnesota's willingness to move the former No. 10 pick after only ten NFL starts is the concern that hangs over the entire deal.
The quarterback debate dominates the episode. Drew and Rob get into Kevin O'Connell's reputation developing quarterbacks, John Harbaugh getting information from Jim Harbaugh about McCarthy's Michigan days, why the Giants chose a young reclamation project instead of simply signing Jimmy Garoppolo or Jake Browning, and what McCarthy would have to become for the trade to justify giving up the pick.
Brian Burns is also officially out for the season with a torn ACL. The guys revisit whether Burns should have been playing at all, separate his existing left-ankle injury from the ACL tear in his right knee, and look at the Giants' options for replacing his pass-rush production.
John Michael Schmitz comes under serious scrutiny after a 19.0 PFF pass-blocking grade against Tennessee, especially because the rest of the offensive line showed improvement. Meanwhile, Arvell Reese turns in his best NFL performance, Francis Mauigoa continues his encouraging transition to guard, and the Giants' limited use of Odell Beckham Jr. remains a talking point.
Then it's around the league for NFL Week 3: Atlanta overwhelms Green Bay, Kansas City moves to 3-0, Cleveland keeps surprising people, Jacksonville crushes New England, Buffalo survives five turnovers, the Raiders keep winning, Baltimore escapes Dallas and Denver flips the Rams game late.
Rob also opens a seven-point lead over Drew in the season picks standings after a huge Week 3.
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The Giants are 2-1 after surviving Tennessee 12-7, but the win came with a major tradeoff: New York found a way to finish a game it might have lost in previous seasons while exposing serious problems on offense, in the pass rush and with late-game execution.
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
Should Giants fans feel good about being 2-1 or worried by how close Tennessee came to stealing this game? 
The answer depends on whether you value the Giants finally finding ways to win ugly games more than the offensive and late-game problems that almost cost them one they controlled.
Jevón Holland was the hero again, intercepting Cam Ward in the end zone to finish the game and adding another massive play to his start with the Giants. Drew and Rob debate whether Holland has already become the most dependable playmaker on this defense.
The win also came with another Brian Burns injury concern. Burns entered the game dealing with an ankle issue, later exited with a right-knee injury, and during the show the update came that he would undergo an MRI. No diagnosis or timetable was available during the episode.
The offense produced no touchdowns. Dominic Zvada kicked four field goals and supplied every Giants point while New York repeatedly moved into scoring territory without finishing. That opens up a much larger discussion about the red-zone play calling and just how much the coaching staff trusted Jameis Winston.
Was the conservative approach smart because Winston was playing in terrible conditions and protecting the football, or did the Giants become so cautious that they made life harder on themselves?
The running-back usage became another major debate. Najee Harris averaged nearly six yards per carry but finished with only nine attempts, while Cam Skattebo received 20 carries. Skattebo still contributed as a receiver and made one of the biggest offensive plays of the afternoon, but Drew and Rob question why the Giants moved away from Harris when he was consistently producing.
Defensively, seven points allowed looks excellent until you look at how the game finished. The Giants never sacked Cam Ward, Tennessee eventually drove 91 yards for a touchdown, and the Titans reached the Giants’ red zone on the final possession before Holland ended it.
Where was the Giants pass rush when Tennessee finally started throwing the football effectively?
New York also piled up costly penalties and mistakes late in the game, giving Tennessee multiple opportunities to turn a 12-0 fourth-quarter deficit into a win. Dominic Zvada and Jordan Stout were outstanding individually on special teams, but the Giants made the finish far more difficult than it ever needed to be.
The Giants survived.
They are 2-1.
And somehow this win gave Giants fans almost as much to argue about as a loss.
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The Giants need another quarterback, but the real question is what they should be willing to sacrifice to get one. Drew and Rob argue that signing Jimmy Garoppolo as veteran insurance makes far more sense than giving away draft capital for a short-term quarterback fix.
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
Should the Giants sign Jimmy Garoppolo instead of trading draft capital for another quarterback?
Drew and Rob say yes — as a veteran No. 2 behind Jameis Winston, not as a replacement starter.
The quarterback discussion starts with the reported Giants interest in Garoppolo and John Harbaugh confirming that another quarterback will be added. Gardner Minshew, Mac Jones, J.J. McCarthy and other possible options come up, but the argument keeps returning to the same issue: why give away a draft pick for a player who may only be needed for the rest of this season when Garoppolo can be added without a trade?
Before moving into the league-wide picks, Drew and Rob react to Dennard Wilson discussing the death of his father before the Rams game and his refusal to use it as an excuse for the defensive performance. They also cover the latest Giants-Titans injury changes, including Andrew Thomas moving from limited to DNP, Brian Burns missing another practice, Malik Nabers returning to full participation and Jameis Winston staying after practice for extra work.
Most of the episode is devoted to NFL Week 3. Drew and Rob make winner, spread and over/under picks across the slate, starting with Giants-Titans and moving through Chiefs-Dolphins, Panthers-Browns, Patriots-Jaguars, Chargers-Bills, Jets-Lions, Texans-Colts, Seahawks-Commanders and Bengals-Steelers.
The late-window games bring Cardinals-49ers, Vikings-Buccaneers and Raiders-Saints before one of the biggest debates of the episode: Ravens-Cowboys in Brazil. Both hosts pick Baltimore to win, but Drew takes the Ravens to cover and the under while Rob gives Dallas the points and leans over.
They finish with Rams-Broncos on Sunday night and Eagles-Bears on Monday night, where the possibility of Case Keenum starting for Chicago becomes a major part of the handicap.
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

Jaxson Dart’s regular season is over, but the Giants still have 15 games to find out whether this roster and coaching staff can keep the season from collapsing. Losing Dart takes away the offense they planned to build around, but it also puts Jameis Winston, John Harbaugh and the rest of this young roster under an immediate microscope.
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
Is the Giants season over without Jaxson Dart? 
Drew and Rob argue that the expectations have changed dramatically, but the remaining season still matters for developing the roster, evaluating the defense and determining which players should be part of the team when Dart returns.
The biggest story is Dart’s knee. The reporting discussed during the episode has his ACL intact while the MCL, PCL and meniscus were damaged badly enough to require surgery. The guys compare his situation with major knee recoveries from Joe Burrow, Carson Palmer, Nick Chubb and Daunte Culpepper and explain why they are much more concerned about losing Dart for 2026 than about whether he can eventually return to form.
So what does the offense become now? Jameis Winston is the starter against Tennessee, but trying to run the same offense designed around Dart’s mobility doesn’t make sense. Drew and Rob expect a more traditional pocket attack built around the run game, play action and easier passing situations. They also debate the available quarterback options and why trading meaningful draft capital for a temporary replacement would be a mistake.
Can the Giants actually keep this season competitive?
That answer starts against Tennessee. The Rams exposed problems along the Giants offensive line, and Jeffrey Simmons gives the Titans a player capable of attacking that weakness immediately. On the other side, the Giants have an opportunity to pressure Tennessee’s young quarterback, lean heavily on Cam Skattebo and prove that the defense can finally become the unit everyone expected.
The guys also go through the latest Giants and Titans injury situations, Brian Daboll returning to MetLife, Darius Slayton landing in Indianapolis with Daniel Jones, and Falcons-Packers to open the Week 3 NFL picks.
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show