2 Giant Goofballs: A NY Giants Podcast

Starting J.J. McCarthy could give the New York Giants the explosive offense they've been missing, but benching Jameis Winston after just 11 minutes of relief work carries its own risk. McCarthy's remarkable fourth-quarter performance nearly rescued a 34-27 loss to the New Orleans Saints and left John Harbaugh facing one of his toughest quarterback decisions.
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
Should J.J. McCarthy replace Jameis Winston as the Giants' starting quarterback?
McCarthy threw for 243 yards in the fourth quarter and led the Giants to 17 unanswered points, but one impressive relief appearance doesn't automatically prove he's ready to start. Drew and Rob examine both sides of the decision and what Harbaugh needs to consider before the Giants face Houston.
The quarterback debate isn't the only controversy following this loss.
Cam Skattebo received ZERO touches against the Saints after his costly fumble against Washington. Skattebo acknowledged being punished, but Harbaugh maintained that his lack of carries wasn't intentional. The Giants' running backs managed only 34 yards on 14 carries, raising serious questions about the offensive line, running back rotation, and Matt Nagy's approach. Drew and Rob discuss why they support Harbaugh holding players accountable while still recognizing the damage an ineffective rushing attack does to the offense.
Was benching Skattebo the right message, even if it may have cost the Giants offensively?
The Giants also had a complete team collapse. Leading 10-0, New York surrendered 34 consecutive points before McCarthy sparked the late comeback. Charlie Jones' kickoff fumble, Winston's interceptions, a defense that allowed 175 rushing yards, and the inability to pressure Tyler Shough all played a role.
Drew and Rob also debate the fourth-quarter clock management, the final incomplete pass to Isaiah Likely, and whether the Giants should have received a defensive pass interference call.
There were reasons for optimism. Malik Nabers finished with 12 receptions for 165 yards, Isaiah Likely continued producing big plays, and Tyrone Tracy Jr. scored twice. But the Giants still couldn't finish the comeback.
With New York sitting at 3-2-1 atop the NFC East, the discussion turns to John Harbaugh's impact on the team's mentality. These Giants refuse to quit, but is improved toughness enough when the same execution problems keep putting them behind?
Plus, injury concerns heading into Houston and the growing pressure on the offensive coaching staff to find a more consistent identity.
The Giants have fight. Now they need to stop requiring miracles just to stay in games.
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The New York Giants have a chance to strengthen their lead in the NFC East, but injuries to Abdul Carter and both starting offensive tackles could threaten their 3-1-1 momentum. Can John Harbaugh's team overcome those losses and keep winning, or are the Giants running out of healthy answers before the Saints arrive?
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
Can the Giants beat the Saints despite their growing injury concerns?
New York has home-field momentum and a defense capable of making life difficult for New Orleans, but missing key contributors could put additional pressure on Jameis Winston and the remaining roster.
Drew and Rob begin with the latest Giants injury concerns, including Abdul Carter, Jermaine Eluemunor, Andrew Thomas, Colton Hood and Tyler Nubin. With Brian Burns already out for the season, the availability of Carter becomes especially important to New York's pass rush.
Matt Nagy believes the Giants have identified ways to improve their running game, but are the actual problems the offensive line and the play calling rather than the running backs? The hosts also question why New York continues to use the J.J. McCarthy package while trying to win games with Winston.
Cam Skattebo's ball-security problems lead to another debate after the running back explains why he removed his wet gloves against Washington. Former Giants kicker Lawrence Tynes also provides an explanation of Dominic Zvada's missed kicks, identifying differences in plant-foot positioning that could be affecting his accuracy.
And then there's the Jaxson Dart trade proposal. Former NFL tackle Terron Armstead suggested a hypothetical deal sending Dart and two first-round picks for Justin Herbert. Drew and Rob have strong opinions about that idea, Herbert's record, and whether the Giants should even consider sacrificing that much for a veteran quarterback.
Could Week 6 create an even bigger opening for the Giants in the NFC East?
The conversation then moves across the NFL with 13 Week 6 game predictions, point spreads, totals and possible upsets.
We start with Saints–Giants and the important question of whether Winston can beat his former team. From there, it's Texans–Jaguars in London, Bears–Falcons, Ravens–Browns, Titans–Colts, and the other early matchups.
One of the biggest stories involves Philadelphia. Jalen Hurts has been ruled out against Carolina after doctors identified a superficial blood clot in his leg. With Tanner McKee taking over, the Eagles face an uncertain stretch that could affect the NFC East standings. The hosts discuss the potential implications for the Giants' upcoming meeting with Philadelphia, without a confirmed timetable for Hurts' return.
The picks continue with Panthers–Eagles, Buccaneers–Steelers, Cardinals–Rams, Chargers–Chiefs and Bills–Raiders, with disagreements over favorites, injuries and which teams deserve more respect.
Sunday Night Football brings another NFC East matchup as the Dallas Cowboys travel to Green Bay. Can Dallas keep pace with the Packers at Lambeau Field, or will Green Bay take advantage of the Cowboys' defensive problems?
We close with Commanders–49ers on Monday Night Football and what the outcome could mean for the division.
The Giants have put themselves in a position that few fans expected this early in the season. Now they need to prove that injuries, turnovers and an inconsistent running game won't stop them from building on that start.
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The Giants have a chance to improve to 4-1-1 against a struggling New Orleans Saints team, and Jameis Winston gets to face his former franchise. But injuries to New York's offensive line and pass rush, combined with ongoing ball-security concerns, could turn an expected Giants victory into another frustrating Sunday.
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
Can Jameis Winston lead the New York Giants past his former team in Week 6?
The Giants have favorable matchups against New Orleans' struggling defense, but protecting Winston, avoiding turnovers, and limiting Tyler Shough will be essential to securing a victory.
Drew previews the New York Giants vs New Orleans Saints matchup with New York sitting at 3-1-1 and leading the NFC East, while New Orleans enters at 1-4. Despite that difference, the Saints are favored on the road.
Can the Giants finally get their running game going?
New Orleans is allowing 148.8 rushing yards and 30.2 points per game. That creates an opportunity for Cam Skattebo, Tyrone Tracy Jr., and the Giants offense to establish the run and open up the passing game. But Skattebo's fumbling problems remain a concern, especially after the costly overtime turnover against Washington.
Jameis Winston's return against New Orleans adds another dimension to the game. Drew discusses Winston's previous years with the Saints, his leadership in New York, his developing chemistry with Malik Nabers and Isaiah Likely, and whether facing his former teammates could provide additional motivation.
Will injuries keep the Giants from taking advantage?
Andrew Thomas and Jermaine Eluemunor both missed Wednesday's practice, creating questions about the matchup against Chase Young and Carl Granderson. Abdul Carter's calf injury adds further uncertainty to a Giants pass rush already missing Brian Burns.
Drew examines whether Dennard Wilson's aggressive defense can exploit Tyler Shough's struggles against pressure, how Chris Olave and Alvin Kamara could threaten New York, and why the Giants cannot afford to underestimate an opponent with a poor record.
The episode also covers the latest New York Giants news, including the offensive line's rise to No. 17 in PFF's rankings, Bryan Hudson's play at center, and the addition of Josh Gesky to the practice squad.
Drew examines whether the Giants deserve more respect in the NFC East race and why the betting markets still favor Philadelphia and Dallas to win the division. John Harbaugh's defense of Kayvon Thibodeaux, Dominic Zvada's kicking mechanics, Cam Skattebo's ball-security issues, and the J.J. McCarthy quarterback package are also discussed.
The episode finishes with the biggest keys to Giants-Saints, the important matchups that could decide the outcome, and a quick Seattle Seahawks vs Denver Broncos Thursday Night Football prediction.
Are the Giants legitimate NFC East contenders, or are their close-game escapes hiding problems that could finally catch up to them?
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The New York Giants signed Dawuane Smoot to the practice squad after also working out Yannick Ngakoue and Julian Okwara. They gain veteran defensive-line depth, but with Brian Burns out for the season and Smoot's recent run-defense grades raising concerns, did they actually get the help they need?
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
THE BIG QUESTION
Should the Giants sign Yannick Ngakoue after adding Dawuane Smoot? Smoot provides experienced rotational depth, but Ngakoue offers a different pass-rushing profile, and the Giants must decide whether another veteran is worth adding.
Drew and Rob examine all three defensive-line workout candidates, Smoot's career production and disappointing recent PFF evaluations, and whether Yannick's previous experience playing for John Harbaugh makes him an attractive option. They also debate the possibility of trading Kayvon Thibodeaux while the Giants are competing for the NFC East lead.
Would moving Thibodeaux now mean selling low on a former first-round pick, especially with Burns already sidelined?
The Giants' coaching adjustments receive plenty of attention as well. John Harbaugh discusses the latest injuries to Jermaine Eluemunor, Tyler Nubin, Colton Hood and Andrew Thomas. Bryan Hudson remains the starting center over John Michael Schmitz, and the offensive line faces questions about its ability to run the ball.
On offense, the Giants finally found success using a faster tempo with Jameis Winston against Washington. Drew and Rob discuss why it worked, Winston's 254 passing yards after halftime and whether Matt Nagy should make no-huddle a regular part of the offense. Defensively, Dennard Wilson has dramatically increased the blitz rate, but can New York sustain that approach against stronger opponents?
Then comes Dan Quinn's explanation of Washington's disastrous overtime finish. The Commanders had a chance to win with a field goal but allowed the clock to expire. Drew and Rob examine the substitutions, communication problems and coaching responsibility behind the 27-27 tie.
The Giants remain 3-1-1 and in first place in the NFC East. Should fans be encouraged by the comeback or frustrated by another missed opportunity to win?
NFL WEEK 5 RECAP
The second half of the episode moves around the league, starting with Tampa Bay's victory over Dallas and Jacksonville's remarkable finish against Philadelphia in London. The Jaguars' last-second field goal leaves the Eagles with another loss and gives Giants fans plenty to enjoy.
Drew and Rob also cover the undefeated Vikings, the Patriots' dominant performance against the Raiders, the Jets' defensive win over Cleveland, Green Bay's victory over Chicago, and Pittsburgh's big offensive day behind Jaylen Warren.
The Texans' trade for Marvin Harrison Jr. sparks a discussion about reuniting him with C.J. Stroud and whether Houston can revive his production.
The late games deliver more drama: Denver beats the Chargers after a controversial fourth-down decision, Jahmyr Gibbs powers Detroit's explosive offense, San Francisco stays undefeated with a narrow win over Seattle, and Baltimore rallies to beat Atlanta in overtime.
Throughout the NFL recap, Drew and Rob revisit their Week 5 winners, point spreads, totals and Trifecta picks, including a disagreement over how one of their picks was recorded.
The Giants are still leading the division, but do they have enough depth and consistency to stay there?
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The New York Giants erased a 14-point fourth-quarter deficit against Washington, only to finish with a frustrating 27-27 overtime tie. Three missed field goals and a costly Cam Skattebo fumble turned a remarkable comeback into a missed opportunity to strengthen New York's NFC East lead.
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
Did the Giants prove they're legitimate NFC East contenders, or did they throw away a game they should have won?
Drew and Rob react to one of the strangest Giants games of the season. Down 14 points in the fourth quarter, Jameis Winston led two crucial touchdown drives to force overtime. Isaiah Likely delivered a massive performance with 11 receptions, 94 yards, and two touchdowns, while Malik Nabers added 121 receiving yards and a touchdown.
But the comeback only tells half the story.
Dominic Zvada missed three field goals, including a critical 46-yard opportunity in overtime. Drew and Rob debate how much blame belongs on the rookie kicker, especially given the rainy and windy conditions. Then Cam Skattebo lost a fumble as the Giants were moving the football in overtime, ending another potential opportunity to win.
The offensive coaching decisions also come under fire. Why did the Giants keep inserting J.J. McCarthy into special packages while Winston was finding his rhythm? Did those substitutions create any real advantage, or were they disrupting an offense that finally started moving the ball?
The guys break down the struggling rushing attack, offensive-line problems, and how the passing game eventually helped create running opportunities.
On defense, Jayden Daniels gave the Giants major problems with his mobility, rushing for 103 yards and two touchdowns. Drew and Rob examine the lack of containment, the missed opportunities to keep Daniels in the pocket, and the defensive plays that helped New York fight back.
Injuries, special teams, coaching adjustments, and Washington's own overtime clock-management disaster all factor into a game neither team managed to win.
Is the comeback something to celebrate, or do the mistakes outweigh everything the Giants accomplished?
New York moves to 3-1-1 and remains in first place in the NFC East. With Dallas and Philadelphia both losing in Week 5, the Giants still gained ground in the division race, but they missed a chance to create even more separation.
Drew and Rob also recap the biggest games and surprises from around the NFL in Week 5, including the Eagles' struggles, the Patriots' impressive offensive performance, and other results shaping the conference standings.
This was a game that gave Giants fans almost every possible emotion. An ugly start, an incredible comeback, costly mistakes, and a 27-27 finish that leaves everyone wondering what could have been.
Would you rather celebrate the comeback or focus on the win that slipped away?
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show