2 Giant Goofballs: A NY Giants Podcast

The Giants can stay at No. 5 and take a premium prospect, but the tradeoff is obvious: they may be forcing a top-five pick in a draft that does not have true top-five value. Is that the wrong bet for this roster? If the board is weak at the top, why force a move that could backfire instead of trading down and building the team the right way?
Follow us on Spotify so you never miss an episode, and if you listen on Apple Podcasts, please leave a 5-star rating and review to help more Giants fans find the show.
Drew and Rob spend most of this episode working through the real problem with the Giants picking fifth overall: this is not viewed as a strong, top-heavy draft, and that makes the risk of forcing a pick much higher. They rule out the obvious non-starters first, including another quarterback after drafting Jaxson Dart and another edge rusher after investing so heavily in Abdul Carter, Brian Burns, and Kayvon Thibodeaux. From there, the conversation keeps coming back to the same question: if the Giants do not love the board, why act like they do?
The linebacker debate gets real attention, especially with Sonny Styles and Arvell Reese, but even there the discussion comes back to value. The same thing happens at safety with Caleb Downs, where talent is acknowledged but the positional value and roster context make No. 5 feel rich. Running back gets the strongest pro-pick push because Jeremiyah Love is viewed as one of the few true difference-makers in the class, yet even that conversation is framed through the lens of board value, roster construction, and whether taking a back that high is actually the smartest use of the pick.
Cornerback, offensive line, and wide receiver all come with some level of appeal, but the episode repeatedly questions whether any of those options are worth forcing at No. 5 in this specific class. That is why the trade-down angle dominates the show. The argument is simple: in a depth-heavy draft, the Giants may be better off moving back, adding picks, and still landing a player who fits what John Harbaugh and the new staff want to build. Instead of chasing a shaky top-five valuation, the smarter move may be stacking assets, filling real holes like corner, guard, or defensive tackle, and giving the roster more long-term help. Take the flashy name now, or avoid the bad priority and build this thing the right way?
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/

Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs

All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

This 2026 NFL Draft running back class gives you burst, receiving value, and a few backs with real starter upside, but the sacrifice is using a meaningful pick on a group that also feels thin, injury-heavy, and full of role-player projections. If a team chases the wrong traits here, are they buying speed and flash while passing on better value somewhere else?
Follow us on Spotify so you do not miss the next live-to-audio upload, and if you enjoy the show, give us a 5-star rating and review on Apple Podcasts.
In this episode, Drew and Rob kick off their 2026 draft coverage by breaking down the running back class from the bottom up and asking the question that hangs over the whole show: is this actually a class worth investing in, or is it a bad year to force a pick at the position? The discussion keeps coming back to the same tradeoff. There is clear upside in this group, but there are also durability concerns, ball-security problems, pass-protection flaws, age concerns, and more than a few backs who feel like complementary pieces instead of true long-term answers.
The show spends time sorting through the role-player and value tier first, including Seth McGowan, Kaelon Black, J’Mari Taylor, Kaytron Allen, Jaydn Ott, and Le’Veon Moss. Some bring size, some bring steady downhill value, and some have enough traits to stick in an NFL backfield, but most of them come with obvious limitations. Whether it is injury history, a capped ceiling, pass-protection concerns, or overlap with what the Giants already have, Drew and Rob make it clear that a lot of these backs feel more like depth options than players you should be excited to spend real capital on.
Then the conversation shifts into the more compelling names in the class. Nicholas Singleton gets real respect for his size, speed, receiving value, and pass protection, but there are still vision and medical questions that keep him from being an automatic RB1. Mike Washington Jr. has the size-speed profile teams love, but the ball-security issue is loud enough to make the projection risky fast. Jonah Coleman gets praised as one of the safer all-around evaluations, even if the big-play ceiling is limited.
The biggest praise in the episode goes to Emmett Johnson, Jadarian Price, and Jeremiyah Love. Emmett Johnson is framed as one of the most underrated backs in the class because of his workload, receiving production, consistency, and overall football value. Jadarian Price gets strong support for his burst, return value, and ability to maximize touches even while sharing a backfield. Jeremiyah Love lands at the top because of the explosive profile, home-run ability, and feature-back upside, even though Drew still pushes back on the idea that he should be treated like some untouchable generational prospect.
By the end, the show is not just ranking backs. It is drawing a line between exciting traits and smart draft value. That is the real debate running through the whole episode: when this class has so many questions attached to it, how early is too early to take a running back, and which of these backs is actually worth betting on?
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/

Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs

All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The Giants gave Jaxson Dart more help with Patrick Ricard, Darnell Mooney and Isaiah Likely, but they also let key spots stay shaky and still look exposed at right guard and corner. Did Joe Schoen really make this roster better, or did he upgrade the fun positions while leaving the biggest pressure points sitting there?
Follow the show on Spotify so you do not miss the next Giants reaction episode. If you listen on Apple Podcasts, leave a 5-star rating and review to help more Giants fans find the show.
Drew and Rob go unit by unit through the roster and argue where the Giants actually improved after free agency and where the roster still feels unfinished. Quarterback gets an even grade because the room did not really change, but the offense around Jaxson Dart is where the excitement kicks in. Patrick Ricard completely changes the run-game conversation, and the show leans hard into how his fit with Cam Skattebo could give the Giants a more old-school, smash-mouth identity. At wide receiver, the group may have lost the best individual player in Wan'Dale Robinson, but the room looks deeper with Darnell Mooney, Calvin Austin III, Isaiah Hodgins and Gunner Olszewski behind Malik Nabers and Darius Slayton. At tight end, Drew and Rob make it very clear they see Isaiah Likely as a major upgrade over Daniel Bellinger, especially with how Likely fits a quarterback like Dart.
That is where the tradeoff starts to matter. The show keeps coming back to the same concern: what good is improving the weapons if right guard is still unsettled and corner still feels like a hole? The offensive line gets a worse grade as it stands today because that spot is still unresolved, and the defense gets a more mixed review depending on the unit. Some areas look stronger. Some still feel incomplete. The overall tone of the episode is optimistic, but not blind optimism. Drew and Rob are excited about what the Giants added, especially on offense and in terms of roster depth, while still pushing the harder question that matters most: did free agency actually solve enough, or did it just make the roster more interesting without fixing the biggest risks?
If you heard the live show, drop your answer: are the Giants truly better right now, or are the holes at right guard and corner still too big to ignore?
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/

Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs

All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

Jason Pinnock gives the Giants a cheap downhill safety they already know, but bringing him back only works if this defense finally uses him the right way. If the Giants ask Pinnock to live in coverage again, is this a smart reunion or just the same mistake all over again?
Follow 2 Giants Goofballs on Spotify so you never miss an episode, and if you listen on Apple Podcasts, leave us a 5-star rating and review to help more Giants fans find the show.
Drew and Rob break down why the Jason Pinnock move is more interesting than it looks on the surface. The numbers from San Francisco were rough, but the bigger argument in this episode is that Pinnock was being used in a role that never matched what he does best. When he can play downhill, attack, and work like a robber-style safety, he looks like a useful player. When he is asked to turn, cover, and move laterally too much, the flaws show up fast. That is why this signing feels like a real debate instead of an easy win. The Giants may have found a cheap fit, or they may be betting on a player they still have not fully figured out.
The episode also gets into the Brian Burns restructure and why freeing up cap room matters even if it is not the kind of move that leads to some massive late free-agent splash. From there, the conversation shifts to Greg Newsome betting on himself in New York, why his press-man mindset fits this defense, and why Isaiah Likely’s comments about Jaxson Dart and John Harbaugh sound like more proof that players are buying into the new direction of this team. There is also more on why not every big name on the market is actually a good fit, and why the Giants’ bigger story right now may be identity more than headlines.
This is the audio from yesterday morning’s live show.
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/

Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs

All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send a text
Support the show

The Giants added real speed and return juice with Calvin Austin III, but they also added another smaller receiver to a room that still has real questions about size, blocking, and true depth. Is this a smart low-cost addition, or are the Giants making another small bet at wide receiver instead of solving the bigger problem?
Follow us on Spotify for more Giants reactions, and if you listen on Apple, please drop a 5-star rating and review to help the show grow.
This episode is built around the Calvin Austin signing because that was the real debate of the night. Drew and Rob break down why the deal itself makes sense on paper at one year and $1.5 million, why the incentives matter, and why Austin’s speed gives this offense something it badly needed. They get into the 4.32 speed, the return ability, the gadget usage, and why Austin could absolutely carve out a role if the Giants use him the right way. They also make the case that fans are too quick to dismiss a player just because he is not a headline name. If Austin gives this team a few hundred receiving yards, return value, and real speed stress, that is strong value on this contract.
At the same time, the episode keeps coming back to the real tradeoff. Austin is still undersized. He is not the guy you want winning jump balls. He is not bringing much as a blocker. And if the Giants keep stacking smaller complementary receivers without adding enough size and complete skill sets around Malik Nabors, are they really building a better room or just adding another specialist? That is the tension running through the entire discussion. The guys also talk about whether Austin is really a Jalin Hyatt replacement, whether Jackson Dart could benefit from this type of weapon, and why the Giants may still need to draft another receiver even after making this move. The overall takeaway is that the contract is good, the role makes sense, and the value is real, but the broader receiver room still feels unfinished.
The rest of the show touches on the other Day 4 moves and reactions, including Chris Board being released, Aaron Stinnie and Ryan Miller returning, the Abdul Carter No. 3 jersey buzz, and media comments from Tremaine Edmunds, Jermaine Eluemunor, Micah McFadden, Patrick Ricard, and Jason Sanders. But the center of gravity is Calvin Austin and what this signing says about how the Giants are trying to build the offense.
This is the audio from yesterday morning’s live show.
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/

Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs

All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show