2 Giant Goofballs: A NY Giants Podcast

The Giants can keep Odell Beckham Jr. and sacrifice a roster spot on a veteran who offers little special-teams value, or cut him after he just showed he can still separate and contribute as an NFL receiver. That same gain-versus-sacrifice decision runs through a roster that still has questions at quarterback, defensive tackle and the bottom of the 53.
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate. It helps more Giants fans find the show.
Should the Giants keep Odell Beckham Jr.? 
Based on what Drew saw against the Jets, cutting OBJ would now be the more surprising decision after Beckham caught 3 passes for 53 yards and consistently created separation.
The bigger on-air concern was Jaxson Dart. If Dart starts against Dallas, he will have gone 29 days without game action. Drew questions whether the Giants became too conservative with a second-year quarterback learning a new Matt Nagy offense, particularly because Dart never played a preseason game after the full foundational install was completed.
Did protecting Jaxson Dart create another risk? Drew argues that practice cannot fully recreate live game reps and worries that a slow start against Dallas could become especially costly with the Rams waiting in Week 2.
The defensive line created another major concern. The Jets opened the game with a 10-play, 65-yard touchdown drive without attempting a pass, exposing the Giants' interior run defense. New York responded by trading a 2028 seventh-round pick to Baltimore for 6'6", 365-pound defensive tackle C.J. Okoye.
But did the Okoye trade actually fix the problem? John Harbaugh made clear the Giants are still looking for opportunities to improve, and Drew views defensive tackle as the biggest unresolved weakness heading into the final roster decisions.
Trace Ford made those decisions even more difficult with 5 tackles, 3 tackles for loss, a sack, 2 quarterback hits and 2 passes defensed. Tyrone Tracy Jr. also responded to earlier preseason mistakes with 37 yards and a touchdown on only 4 carries, while Najee Harris finally returned to game action following his Achilles rehab.
Dominic Zvada officially won the kicking job after a perfect preseason. Drew also works through the remaining bubble cases involving Braxton Berrios, Zaire Barnes, Jack Kelly, Francis “Sisi” Mauigoa, Korie Black, Jake Haener, Jameis Winston and Evan Neal.
The roster movement has already started. Ugo Amadi, Damon Bankston, Josiah Deguara, Leki Fotu, Isaiah Hodgins, Brenden Jaimes, Anfernee Orji and Kobe Prentice were released as the Giants began working toward the initial 53.
The preseason is finished. Now the question is which performances actually earned roster spots — and where the Giants still need outside help before Dallas.
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The Giants could use cutdown week to strengthen multiple weak spots, but chasing the wrong name could mean spending a roster spot without actually improving the team.
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
Which position should the Giants prioritize after NFL roster cuts? 
Cornerback and defensive tackle produced the strongest arguments in this episode, while wide receiver becomes more complicated after Calvin Austin III's injury.
Arik Armstead is the dream defensive-line addition, but Drew and Rob both question whether Jacksonville would actually make him available now. Kris Jenkins Jr. and McKinnley Jackson create a different kind of opportunity: younger defensive tackles with draft pedigree who could get squeezed by Cincinnati's crowded room.
Could Kristian Fulton be the most realistic impact target? Drew closes the show with Fulton as the player he most hopes becomes available because the Giants still need more confidence at corner. Bilhal Kone, Kader Kohou, Amani Oruwariye and Keyon Martin offer additional possibilities at different levels of experience and upside.
Cedric Tillman creates the most immediate decision because Cleveland has already moved on. At 26, the former third-round pick gives New York size and developmental upside on the outside. The debate is whether that is more valuable than finding a speed-and-return option such as Mecole Hardman or simply trusting Braxton Berrios.
The deeper cutdown board includes Aeneas Peebles, Broderick Washington Jr., C.J. Okoye, Nikko Remigio, Gerad Lichtenhan, Rayshaun Benny and Matt Dickerson. These are not headline additions, but cutdown weekend is often about improving the bottom of the roster as much as finding another starter.
Does New York chase the biggest name available, or target the specific holes that could hurt them most once the season starts?
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The Giants gained flexibility elsewhere on the roster, but Calvin Austin III’s season-ending ACL tear takes away a receiver who had earned a real offensive and return role just before final cuts. Now New York has to redistribute that work without weakening a WR room already depending heavily on Malik Nabers’ health.
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
The Big Question: Who replaces Calvin Austin III in the Giants offense? 
Braxton Berrios is the clearest true-slot option, but Odell Beckham Jr., Malachi Fields and the rest of the room could all see their roles change.
Drew and Rob break down what Austin’s loss means for Berrios, OBJ, Fields, Darnell Mooney and the final 53. Darius Slayton said Austin had earned the right to start and make an impact, which makes this much bigger than losing a fringe roster player.
Jaxson Dart is also giving Matt Nagy more reasons for optimism. The Giants are expanding the terminology around him, working on when he needs to protect himself as a runner, and seeing more success downfield in practice. Dart threw four touchdowns in eight goal-line plays, and the debate becomes whether this is a real Year 2 step or simply August optimism.
Malik Nabers is back taking team reps without the red non-contact jersey, making Week 1 against Dallas a legitimate possibility. The hosts debate whether a snap count makes sense if Nabers is close but not fully ready.
The running back room has its own pressure. Cam Skattebo sits atop the latest unofficial depth chart, while Tyrone Tracy is trying to rebound from a missed blitz pickup and a preseason fumble. Skattebo’s practice scuffle with Greg Newsome II and Jevon Holland also turns into a discussion about how much edge is too much when it is directed at teammates.
Deonte Banks’ resurgence under Dennard Wilson, the Daniel Faalele and Josh Ezeudu trades, and the remaining defensive tackle concern round out the Giants roster discussion. The episode also gets into the NFL ending the traditional Pro Bowl games while keeping Pro Bowl selections.
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

Keeping Odell Beckham Jr. gives the Giants a proven veteran, a respected voice in the receiver room and a player fans still want to see in blue — but that roster spot may cost New York younger upside, special-teams value or needed depth elsewhere. Drew and Rob build their projected 53-man roster and find out quickly that every extra player creates another painful cut.
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
Should the Giants keep OBJ on the 53-man roster?
The case comes down to whether Beckham's receiving and veteran value outweigh what players like Dalen Cambre and Braxton Berrios can provide through youth, development and special teams.
The longest argument centers on the wide receiver room. Drew keeps six — Malik Nabers, Darius Slayton, Darnell Mooney, Calvin Austin III, Malachi Fields and Braxton Berrios — and leaves both OBJ and Cambre off the initial 53. Rob pushes back on OBJ, arguing that his presence still has real value for the team and fan base. Drew counters that if the Giants find another receiver spot, he would rather protect Cambre's long-term upside than use it on a veteran nearing the end of his career.
Can the Giants really afford 10 offensive linemen? J.C. Davis' strong preseason forces that question. Davis looks too risky to expose to waivers, while Josh Ezeudu's versatility, Lucas Patrick's backup-center role and the Bryan Hudson decision make the final offensive-line spots difficult. Evan Neal is projected out as the new coaching staff continues reshaping a room that has been a problem for years.
The defensive cuts turn into a special-teams argument. Zaire Barnes gets the edge over Darius Muasau because of his value in the kicking game, Korie Black and Art Green battle for the final cornerback spot, and Elijah Campbell becomes one of the hardest players to leave off. Drew's roster cannot keep a dedicated special-teams answer at every position, so somebody useful has to lose.
At kicker, Dominic Zvada gets the nod over Ben Sauls. More broadly, the entire exercise comes with one major unknown: nobody has seen John Harbaugh build a Giants 53-man roster before. His priorities on special teams, versatility and inherited players could make the real cutdown look very different from what Giants fans are used to.
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The Giants’ 26-3 win over Miami showed better depth, physicality and execution, but it also made the roster decisions harder—especially at running back. Tyrone Tracy flashed again, yet another costly mistake put his role and John Harbaugh’s trust in the middle of the biggest debate of the episode.
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
The Big Question: Did the Giants’ 26-3 preseason win show real progress, or was Miami too depleted to tell? The performance gave New York legitimate positives in depth and execution, but Drew and Rob agreed the real proof still has to come against NFL starters in the regular season.
Tracy’s fumble inside Miami territory turned into the longest argument of the show. Drew pushed back on the idea that two preseason mistakes erase two seasons of production, while the conversation shifted to Devin Singletary’s consistency, Najee Harris returning to the mix, Cam Skattebo’s place in the room and whether the Giants can realistically carry all four backs.
The secondary was another major point of debate. Greg Newsome and Paulson Adebo looked encouraging, Deonte Banks continued to make plays, Dru Phillips forced two fumbles but still drew criticism for his coverage, and Tyler Nubin again looked more comfortable around the football. The question is whether the improvement is real or simply a product of preseason competition.
The offensive line depth came out of Miami looking better than it has in years, with J.C. Davis and Marcus Mbow among the positives. The wide receiver room got even more crowded as Darius Slayton produced, Calvin Austin III showed multiple ways to help, Odell Beckham Jr. continued creating separation but missed a touchdown chance, and Dalen Cambre kept making a case on offense and special teams.
Darius Alexander’s run defense remains a concern, Dominic Zvada appears to be gaining ground in the kicking competition, and Chris Mara’s message that “hope has turned into expectations” raised the stakes around John Harbaugh’s first season.
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show