2 Giant Goofballs: A NY Giants Podcast

Joe Schoen protected the New York Giants' draft picks at the NFL trade deadline, but that decision puts more pressure on Cam Skattebo and a rushing attack that has struggled without him. Would acquiring Jonathan Taylor have improved a first-place Giants team enough to justify the cost?
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
Did Joe Schoen make a mistake at the NFL trade deadline? 
The answer depends on what the Giants would have surrendered for an upgrade, especially when their offensive line may be a bigger weakness than their running backs.
Drew and Rob open with the Giants' Thursday Night Football matchup against the Washington Commanders. New York is 5-2-1 and leading the NFC East, with Cam Skattebo returning from injury and several important players available. The hosts discuss J.J. McCarthy, Malik Nabers, Abdul Carter, Washington's offensive-line injuries, and Arvell Reese's NFC Defensive Player of the Week performance. They also give their Giants–Commanders score predictions.
The NFL trade deadline then takes center stage. Drew and Rob examine reports that the Giants offered Indianapolis a 2027 second-round pick and a 2028 fifth-round pick for Jonathan Taylor, with uncertainty surrounding the full terms. Would giving up more draft capital have been justified for a veteran running back?
The Giants also reportedly contacted Atlanta about Bijan Robinson. Unlike Taylor, Robinson represents a younger, long-term option, but Atlanta showed no interest in moving him. Drew and Rob debate how much New York should have been willing to surrender, whether Tony Pollard or Justice Hill would have made sense, and why the Giants failed to add defensive-line help.
What if the biggest problem isn't the running backs?
That question drives one of the show's strongest arguments. The offensive line has struggled, several players are dealing with injuries, and even an elite running back needs adequate blocking. Drew and Rob discuss why improving the offensive line might have been more valuable than paying a premium for Jonathan Taylor. They also examine John Harbaugh's comments about avoiding bad deals and the responsibility facing Joe Schoen.
The conversation then shifts to NFL Week 10 picks and predictions, with Drew and Rob working through the league's matchups, debating winners, point spreads, over/unders, quarterback situations, and injuries.
The international game between the Patriots and Lions opens the picks. Can Drake Maye keep New England competitive against Detroit's explosive offense? The hosts also debate whether Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs can handle Bijan Robinson and Atlanta, and whether Deshaun Watson can lead Cleveland past his former team, Houston.
The Vikings–Packers matchup creates another major discussion. Minnesota's acquisition of Kirk Cousins, Green Bay's injuries, and the uncertainty at quarterback lead to a debate about both teams' playoff outlooks. Drew and Rob also consider what a Vikings–Giants playoff matchup could look like with J.J. McCarthy facing his former team.
Jonathan Taylor returns to the discussion when Indianapolis hosts Miami. The Colts have kept their star running back, while the Dolphins are dealing with quarterback injuries. From there, the picks continue with Panthers–Saints, Bills–Jets, and Jaguars–Titans.
Can the Cowboys keep up with San Francisco, or will Dallas fall further behind the Giants in the NFC East?
Drew and Rob debate that crucial divisional implication along with the Rams–Cardinals and Seahawks–Raiders matchups. Injuries, inexperienced quarterbacks, and unpredictable offenses make several of these games more interesting than their records suggest.
The show wraps up with Sunday Night Football between Pittsburgh and Cincinnati, where Joe Burrow, Ja'Marr Chase, and the Bengals face a Steelers team dealing with defensive injuries. The final matchup features the Chargers against the Ravens, with Baltimore adjusting to life without Lamar Jackson.
Who made the right moves at the deadline, which teams are being overrated in Week 10, and can the Giants keep building their lead in the NFC East?
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The New York Giants finally broke their Philadelphia road losing streak with a 19-11 victory over the Eagles, but the win exposed serious problems with the offensive line and running game. Big Blue sits atop the NFC East at 5-2-1, yet protecting that lead could require significant improvements on offense.
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
Can the New York Giants win the NFC East with their current offensive line?
The defense is playing well enough to give New York a legitimate opportunity, but quarterback protection, rushing production, and injuries could determine whether the Giants turn their division lead into a playoff appearance.
For the first time since 2013, the Giants have won on the road in Philadelphia. Drew and Rob celebrate ending the streak, but neither host overlooks how difficult it was for New York to move the football. The Giants finished with only 243 offensive yards and relied heavily on an outstanding defensive performance to secure the victory.
Arvell Reese delivered another remarkable game with 12 tackles, three sacks, three tackles for loss, and a forced fumble. The hosts discuss whether Reese deserves Defensive Player of the Year consideration, how Dennard Wilson has adjusted his defense to available personnel, and why Micah McFadden and DJ Reader deserve recognition. They also revisit a game in which the Giants sacked Philadelphia seven times and held former Giant Saquon Barkley to 22 rushing yards.
The offense creates a much more complicated conversation. J.J. McCarthy completed 12 of 19 passes for 127 yards before and after dealing with a hip injury. Jameis Winston stepped in and helped produce New York's only touchdown drive, connecting with Isaiah Likely for the score. Drew and Rob question whether McCarthy should have returned, particularly with another divisional game approaching on a short week.
The running game was equally concerning. Devin Singletary finished with 31 yards on 21 attempts while the Giants rushed for only 80 yards overall. The hosts examine the offensive line's PFF grades, criticize Jon Runyan's recent performances, discuss the learning curve for Francis Mauigoa, and question whether Greg Desrosiers Jr. should receive additional carries.
Should the Giants consider changing the offensive line before the problems cost them a division game?
Malik Nabers becomes another major topic following Greg Olsen's criticism of his sideline body language during the Eagles game. Drew and Rob debate whether the broadcast criticism was fair, distinguish competitive frustration from being a bad teammate, and discuss the broader tendency to overanalyze emotional wide receivers.
Special teams also get attention, including Dominic Zvada's four successful field goals, the problems involving Charlie Jones, and the importance of punting and field position in such a tight defensive game.
The conversation shifts into a rapid-fire review of NFL Week 9, covering the biggest results around the league and Drew and Rob's weekly picks competition. Rob takes a five-point advantage into the remaining Monday Night Football matchup.
With the trade deadline approaching, the hosts debate how aggressive the Giants should be. Jonathan Taylor remains an intriguing possibility, but reporting discussed during the episode suggests a deal is unlikely. Drew and Rob consider whether giving up premium draft capital for a running back is worth the cost and whether defensive tackle would be a more affordable target.
Is adding one offensive playmaker worth sacrificing future draft picks, or should New York trust its defense and existing roster?
Finally, the Giants prepare for Thursday Night Football against the Washington Commanders. The teams tied 27-27 in their first meeting, a game featuring missed opportunities, late scoring, and major mistakes on both sides.
Drew and Rob revisit Jayden Daniels' rushing production, Washington's recent offensive problems, potential injuries, and the defensive matchups that could decide the rematch. The hosts also discuss whether Malik Nabers is positioned for a big performance and how Arvell Reese could be used to contain Daniels.
The Giants have a real opportunity to strengthen their hold on the NFC East. Winning in Philadelphia was a major step, but beating Washington may be an even more important test of whether this team is ready to compete for the division title.
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

Jonathan Taylor could give the New York Giants a premier running back for their NFC East push, but acquiring him could cost valuable draft picks that Joe Schoen needs to build the roster.
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
The Big Question: Is Jonathan Taylor worth multiple draft picks for the New York Giants?
Drew and Rob question whether the Giants should surrender significant draft capital for a running back when the team has other needs, particularly along the defensive line. With the November 10 NFL trade deadline approaching, Indianapolis has reportedly received an offer from New York, and the Colts are holding out for substantial compensation.
The discussion gets especially heated when the hosts react to a proposed three-pick package and counteroffer described in The Athletic's trade-negotiation exercise. Would paying a second-, third-, and fourth-round pick be too much? Would Taylor provide enough long-term value? And could the Giants find a less expensive alternative?
The episode begins with the Giants preparing for their NFC East showdown against the Philadelphia Eagles. New York is favored, but Malik Nabers and Cam Skattebo are dealing with injuries, while Philadelphia has availability questions involving Saquon Barkley, DeVonta Smith, and other key contributors. Drew and Rob make their predictions and debate whether the Giants can take advantage of the Eagles' struggles.
Malik Nabers also earned NFC Offensive Player of the Month honors after a dominant October. Is he already one of the NFL's five best receivers? The hosts also discuss Derrick Brown trade possibilities, John Harbaugh's confidence in rookie kicker Dominic Zvada, and Tom Coughlin's latest Hall of Fame consideration.
Then it's time for NFL Week 9 predictions across the league. Drew and Rob debate outright winners, point spreads, totals, quarterback changes, and potential upsets, including Bengals–Falcons, Cowboys–Colts, Packers–Patriots, Chiefs–Jets, and Raiders–49ers.
Which big NFL favorites are vulnerable against the spread?
The show finishes with Cardinals–Seahawks, Buccaneers–Bears on Sunday Night Football, and Bills–Vikings on Monday Night Football. From backup quarterback uncertainty in Seattle and Minnesota to the pressure facing Josh Allen against Brian Flores' defense, Week 9 offers plenty of opportunities for surprises.
For Giants fans, the question is bigger than one weekend: should New York sacrifice future draft capital to strengthen its chances of winning the NFC East right now?
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The New York Giants can strengthen their NFC East lead with a victory in Philadelphia, but losing to an Eagles team riding a six-game losing streak would be a major setback. Meanwhile, a potential Jonathan Taylor trade could address New York's running back concerns at the cost of valuable draft capital.
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
The Big Question: Is Giants vs. Eagles a trap game for New York?
The Giants enter Philadelphia as NFC East leaders, facing a 2-6 Eagles team turning to Joe Milton III at quarterback. New York has the advantage on paper, but Philadelphia's rivalry history, Milton's mobility, and the Giants' struggles defending the run make this matchup more complicated than the standings suggest.
Drew and Rob debate whether the Giants should pressure Milton aggressively or prioritize keeping him in the pocket. They examine Philadelphia's struggling offense, the Giants' defensive weaknesses, and J.J. McCarthy's opportunity to build on his success against Vic Fangio's defense following the bye week.
Can New York finally take advantage of a vulnerable Eagles team, or could overlooking Philadelphia threaten its division lead?
Injuries add another layer of uncertainty. Cam Skattebo's hamstring injury raises questions about the Giants' running back depth, while Abdul Carter's illness creates additional defensive concerns. Philadelphia is also dealing with significant injuries, including concerns surrounding Saquon Barkley and DeVonta Smith. Drew and Rob discuss how these potential absences could influence Sunday's game.
Should the Giants pay the price for Jonathan Taylor?
ESPN's Jordan Raanan reports that New York has made an offer for Jonathan Taylor, although no agreement has been announced. Drew and Rob debate Indianapolis' reported asking price, whether the Giants should surrender premium draft picks, and whether defensive tackle help might provide greater value.
The conversation also covers Greg Newsome II's reported three-year, $46 million extension, the debate over how much immediate salary cap space it creates, and reports that Deonte Banks declined a separate extension offer. Is Banks right to bet on himself, and what does Newsome's deal mean for the Giants' secondary?
Can Baltimore survive Thursday Night Football without its starting quarterbacks?
The Jacksonville Jaguars visit the Baltimore Ravens with rookie Joe Fagnano expected to start at quarterback. Drew and Rob debate whether Derrick Henry can carry Baltimore against Jacksonville's strong defense, examine the Jacoby Brissett trade situation, and offer their predictions for the game.
From the NFC East race to the NFL trade deadline, the Giants face important decisions that could shape the rest of their season.
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The New York Giants gained ground in the NFC East without playing a single snap, but turning their division lead into a championship run could require sacrificing valuable draft picks. With Big Blue sitting at 4-2-1 and the trade deadline approaching, John Harbaugh and Joe Schoen face a tough decision: make an aggressive move now or protect the team's future?
Follow on Spotify and leave a 5-star rating on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy no-BS Giants debate.
Can the Giants win the NFC East without making an expensive trade? 
New York leads the division, but Drew and Rob argue that addressing the run defense could be more valuable than spending premium draft capital on a star running back.
The Giants' bye week couldn't have worked out much better. Dallas blew a 14-point fourth-quarter lead against Arizona and lost 33-30 in overtime, while Philadelphia suffered its sixth consecutive defeat in a 27-10 loss to Washington. New York now sits atop the NFC East at 4-2-1, with every division rival below .500. Drew and Rob debate whether the Giants have legitimately become the division's best team or are benefiting from the struggles of their rivals.
But first place creates pressure of its own.
John Harbaugh confirmed that he contacted Titans owner Amy Adams Strunk in an attempt to pursue defensive tackle Jeffery Simmons before the Bears completed the trade. The Giants have also reportedly explored Daron Payne and shown interest in Colts running back Jonathan Taylor.
With Taylor's reported asking price remaining high, would adding another offensive star really be worth the cost?
Drew and Rob examine the potential price of a Jonathan Taylor trade, discuss Breece Hall and Tony Pollard as possible alternatives, and argue over whether the Giants should instead prioritize defensive tackles Christian Barmore and Grover Stewart. Improving the team's run defense could make an already competitive Giants team substantially more dangerous without sacrificing the draft capital required for a blockbuster move.
Is Grover Stewart actually a better Giants trade target than Jonathan Taylor?
The discussion turns to why defensive tackle may be New York's biggest roster weakness and whether building a dominant defense gives the Giants their best chance to win the division.
The guys also examine Cam Skattebo's uncertain injury status heading into Philadelphia, Tyrone Tracy Jr.'s injured reserve designation, and Eric Gray's return to the practice squad. With two crucial NFC East matchups approaching, the Giants need to capitalize on the opportunity their rivals have handed them.
Are the Eagles really as bad as their six-game losing streak suggests?
Philadelphia's continued struggles put additional pressure on Nick Sirianni ahead of the Giants' upcoming visit. Drew and Rob examine the Eagles' offensive problems, the significance of Washington's 27-10 victory, and why New York should be expected to compete for the division title.
The second half of the episode features the full NFL Week 8 recap and the weekly picks competition.
The guys revisit Arizona's comeback against Dallas, Buffalo's dominant victory over Baltimore, Cincinnati's overtime win against Tennessee, Detroit handing Minnesota its first loss, Jacksonville crushing Indianapolis, Tampa Bay's unusual rain-soaked shutout of Atlanta, Denver's comeback against Kansas City, and the rest of the NFL action.
Along the way, Drew and Rob compare their predictions, point spreads, over/unders, and weekly scores while sharing plenty of opinions about the Cowboys, Eagles, Jets, and the rest of the league.
The Giants are in first place. The division is theirs to fight for. But can they take advantage without making a costly mistake at the trade deadline?
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show