2 Giant Goofballs: A NY Giants Podcast

The Giants added Shelby Harris and Leki Fotu on the same day, giving New York badly needed defensive tackle help after the Dexter Lawrence trade. The gain is clear: more size, experience, and run-defense options up front. The sacrifice is just as clear: neither player is a true Dexter replacement by himself, so is this a real defensive line plan or just the Giants stacking bodies and hoping the rotation holds?
Follow 2 Giants Goofballs on Spotify, and if you listen on Apple Podcasts, leave a 5-star rating and review to help more Giants fans find the show.
Drew and Rob break down a busy Giants news night after New York signed two defensive tackles before the show even got rolling. Shelby Harris is the bigger name and the more proven piece. He brings 146 career games, 89 starts, and a profile that fits what the Giants need most right now: veteran run-defense help, pocket push, and someone who can help keep linebackers clean. But the debate is not whether Harris can help. The debate is whether a 34-year-old veteran, turning 35 before the season, is enough to stabilize a defensive line that just lost one of the best interior players in football.
The second signing, Leki Fotu, makes the conversation even more interesting. Fotu gives the Giants a massive interior body, which matters because they still need size in the middle. But expectations have to be realistic. This is not a splash signing. It is a depth and rotation move. The Giants appear to be rebuilding the defensive tackle room with multiple pieces instead of one direct Dexter Lawrence replacement, and that creates the real question: can a group approach work, or do they still need D.J. Reader, Calais Campbell, or another veteran before fans should feel comfortable?
Drew and Rob also connect the defensive tackle plan to the rest of the defense. If Harris, Fotu, Roy Robertson-Harris, Darius Alexander, and the rest of the rotation can occupy blockers and tighten the run defense, it could free up the Giants’ linebackers and edge rushers to make more plays. That matters even more after Abdul Carter led the NFL in quick pressures in 2025, getting to the quarterback in under 2.5 seconds more than stars like Nik Bonitto, Will Anderson Jr., Micah Parsons, and Myles Garrett. Carter’s late-season surge has the guys asking whether a breakout year is coming.
The show also covers Jeremy Shockey’s huge praise for Francis Mauigoa, including his claim that Mauigoa could be an All-Pro guard right away if the Giants move him inside. That turns into a larger discussion about the Giants’ draft class, the optimism around John Harbaugh, and why national outlets and bettors are suddenly showing real interest in Big Blue. Sports Illustrated listed the Giants near the top of its worst-to-first candidates, and after the draft, New York became one of the most-bet NFC teams to make the Super Bowl.
Drew and Rob also react to Russell Wilson visiting the Jets, what his post-Giants future looks like, and why his legacy conversation has become complicated after several rough seasons. The episode closes with a serious note on the passing of former Giants linebacker Josh Mauro and a reminder of how young 35 really is.
So where should Giants fans land on this defensive tackle plan? Is Harris a smart veteran pickup? Is Fotu just depth, or can he carve out a useful nose tackle role? And if the Giants are not done, who still needs to be added before this defensive line feels good enough for 2026?
Merch:
 https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support:
 https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes:
 
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The Giants gain cheap post-draft competition with this UDFA and rookie minicamp class, but they also have to sort real roster paths from camp bodies who may never make it past the spring. The biggest question is whether players like Thaddeus Dixon, Dominic Zvada, Daman Bankston, Ben Mann, Ben Barten, Ryan Schernecke, Anquin Barnes Jr., and Dodji Dahoue can actually push for roles, or whether this is just another round of post-draft roster churn.
Follow the show on Spotify so you never miss a Giants episode, and leave us a 5-star rating and review on Apple Podcasts if you enjoy the show. Which Giants long shot has the best chance to stick?
Drew and Rob break down the Giants’ undrafted rookie free agents and rookie minicamp invites after the 2026 NFL Draft, starting with the players who may have the clearest path to matter. Thaddeus Dixon gets a major spotlight because he was not just a random signing. The Giants had him in for a Top 30 visit, and his outside corner profile fits what this defense wants to do: more press, more physicality, and less of the soft coverage that has frustrated fans for years. If there is one defensive UDFA who feels like he was specifically targeted, Dixon belongs high on that list.
The specialist overhaul is another major theme. Dominic Zvada brings a massive leg and a real long-distance kicking résumé, but the conversation is not just hype. His great seasons were excellent, his down seasons raise fair questions, and the Giants now have a real kicking competition after years of instability. Ben Mann also enters the picture at long snapper, where the Giants appear to be resetting the operation after Casey Kreiter left and veteran Zach Triner arrived. It is not flashy, but with John Harbaugh’s special teams background, these battles matter more than fans may realize.
The guys also work through the defensive line additions, including Anquin Barnes Jr. and Ben Barten. Barnes brings traits, size, and major-program background from Alabama and Colorado, but the production was limited enough to make Drew skeptical. Barten, meanwhile, has Big Ten starting experience, run-defense size, academic All-Big Ten honors, and an interesting special teams angle after blocking multiple kicks at Wisconsin. Neither player should be sold as a Dexter Lawrence replacement, but both help fill out a position group that needed bodies and competition.
On offense, Daman Bankston may be one of the more intriguing names because his best path might not be as a traditional running back. His speed, receiving growth, and kick-return production give him a real angle if he can prove he belongs on special teams. Ryan Schernecke gives the Giants a massive developmental tackle from Kutztown with real size and small-school production, while Dodji Dahoue is the raw international offensive line project with rare height, limited football experience, and a possible international pathway that could make him easier to stash and develop.
The episode closes with the rookie minicamp invite list, including Evan Simon, Josh Kreutz, Derek Robertson, A.J. Pena, Cam Miller, Kenny Fletcher Jr., Jalen Berger, Nick Dawkins, and Trebor Pena. Most rookie camp invites never become anything, but this is the time of year when one strong weekend can turn into a longer opportunity. For Giants fans, the debate is simple: who is just a name on a spring roster, and who has enough of a path to make this summer interesting?
Merch:
 https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/

Support:
 https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs

All episodes:
 
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The Giants walked away with Arvell Reese, Francis Mauigoa, Colton Hood, Malachi Fields, and a tougher-looking draft class, but the cost of trading up for Fields is the move that could backfire. Did Joe Schoen build a more physical Giants roster, or did he pay too much for a receiver who still has real projection risk?
Follow the show on Spotify so you never miss a Giants reaction episode. If you listen on Apple Podcasts, leave us a 5-star rating and review to help more Giants fans find the show.
Drew and Rob break down the full New York Giants draft class and give their grades after a weekend that brought excitement, surprise, and plenty of debate. The episode starts with Arvell Reese at No. 5, a pick the guys viewed as a shock because they did not expect him to fall that far. Reese is discussed as a true linebacker, not just an edge rusher, with the ability to stop the run, blitz, spy mobile quarterbacks, and move around enough to make the defense more dangerous.
From there, the conversation turns to Francis Mauigoa at No. 10, the pick acquired through the Dexter Lawrence trade. The big debate is not just Mauigoa himself, but the fact that the Giants passed on Caleb Downs twice. Drew and Rob argue that Mauigoa may not be the flashy pick, but protecting Jaxson Dart and building a tougher offensive line matters more than chasing the sexier name. They frame him as a possible guard early, a mauling run blocker, and a tone-setting piece for the kind of offense John Harbaugh and Greg Roman want to build.
Colton Hood may be the pick Drew loved most. The show digs into why Hood fits Dennard Wilson’s defense, why his press-man style matters, and why the Texans trading up for Kayden McDonald right before the Giants does not automatically mean the Giants got jumped. Hood is praised as a physical, confident outside corner with real swagger and a path to becoming a major piece in the secondary.
The strongest argument of the episode comes with Malachi Fields. The Giants traded picks 105, 145, and a future fourth to move up to No. 74, and Drew makes it clear he thinks that was too much. Rob pushes back by arguing that if Fields becomes the player the Giants believe he can be, the cost may end up looking justified. That becomes the central tension of the episode: is the value of the player enough to excuse the price of the move? Fields brings size, contested-catch ability, blocking value, and a different body type to the receiver room, but the concerns about separation and the cost of the trade keep this from being a clean win.
The episode closes with the Day 3 picks, including Bobby Jamison-Travis, J.C. Davis, and Jack Kelly. Jamison-Travis is discussed as a true run-stopping defensive tackle with a real chance to earn a rotational role after the Dexter Lawrence trade. Davis is viewed as a powerful run blocker with possible guard projection if the Giants can clean up his pass-blocking technique. Kelly is framed as a tough, old-school linebacker and special teams candidate who could eventually become a fan favorite.
Drew gives the draft a B-plus, while Rob lands at an A-minus. The disagreement is not about whether the Giants got more physical. They did. The disagreement is whether the Malachi Fields trade-up was smart aggression or an overpay that lowered the ceiling of the class grade. Giants fans, what letter grade are you giving this draft: A, B, C, D, or F — and which pick made or broke the grade for you?
Merch:
 https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/
Support:
 https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs
All episodes:
 
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The Giants got Colton Hood in Round 2, but the night turned when Houston jumped one spot ahead and took Kayden McDonald before New York could get him. Then the Giants answered by trading back into Round 3 for Malachi Fields, giving up a 4th and 5th this year plus a 4th next year — but was that the right bet or an overpay?
Follow the show on Spotify so you never miss a Giants reaction episode. If you listen on Apple Podcasts, leave a 5-star rating and a review to help more Giants fans find the show.
Drew and Rob recap a wild Day 2 of the NFL Draft for the New York Giants, starting with the second-round selection of Colton Hood. The Giants needed help at corner, and Hood gives them a physical, competitive defensive back with the kind of press-man traits this roster badly needed. But the bigger conversation is what happened one pick before: the Texans jumped ahead and took defensive tackle Kayden McDonald, a player many Giants fans had circled as a possible Dexter Lawrence replacement option after the trade.
That miss set up the real debate of the night. Instead of sitting tight, the Giants made an aggressive move back into the third round to grab Notre Dame wide receiver Malachi Fields. Fields brings size, physicality, and a different body type to the receiver room, but the cost was massive: a fourth-round pick, a fifth-round pick, and a future fourth. For a team that already gave up draft capital and still has holes, that price has to be questioned.
Was Fields worth that kind of move? Did the Giants panic after losing McDonald? Or did Joe Schoen and John Harbaugh correctly identify a player they believed should not have made it out of the third round? This episode breaks down the value, the risk, the roster fit, and what Day 2 says about the Giants’ draft plan moving forward.
Merch:
 https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/

Support:
 https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs

All episodes:
 https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show

The Giants landed Arvell Reese at No. 5 and Francis Mauigoa at No. 10, giving John Harbaugh a new defensive chess piece and Jaxson Dart a mauling blocker up front. But making those two picks meant passing on Caleb Downs twice, and that is the tradeoff driving this episode: did the Giants fix the right problems, or leave the bigger impact player on the board?
Follow the show on Spotify so you do not miss the full draft fallout, and if you are listening on Apple Podcasts, leave a 5-star rating and review to help more Giants fans find the show.
In this live Round 1 reaction episode, Drew and Rob go from all the final pre-draft smoke around Caleb Downs to the shock of Arvell Reese still being there at No. 5. The reaction to Reese is real and mixed in the best way: they clearly understand the upside, the explosiveness, the flexibility, and why a lot of people saw him as one of the best non-quarterbacks in the class, but they also wrestle with the biggest question attached to him. Is Reese going to be used as a true off-ball linebacker, or is the Giants staff going to get too cute and create the same kind of role confusion that has hurt other hybrid defenders before? That tension sits right at the center of the first half of the show.
Then the episode turns to the bigger emotional split of the night. When the Giants come back up at No. 10, Drew and Rob are staring right at the Caleb Downs decision, and the Giants go Francis Mauigoa instead. That shifts the conversation from pure defensive talent to roster-building philosophy. Mauigoa is a huge, physical lineman who fits what the Giants want to become up front, especially if the plan is to protect Dart, run the ball with more force, and finally stop patching the offensive line with short-term fixes. But was that the right move when Downs was still sitting there? Was this the smart trench-building play, or did the Giants pass on the cleaner blue-chip defender to force a roster need instead?
The show leans into both sides of that argument. Reese is framed as a premium talent the Giants probably did not expect to reach them, and Mauigoa is treated as a real answer to a real problem. At the same time, the disappointment over missing out on Downs is not hidden or softened, especially because so much pre-draft conversation made it feel like he was a legitimate Giants target. It is a fan-first reaction episode built around one simple Round 1 question: did the Giants just set up a stronger foundation, or did they let the best defensive answer walk away?
Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/

Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs

All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/
Send us Fan Mail
Support the show