When Betsy Faria was found stabbed to death in her Missouri home, suspicion quickly fell on her husband, Russ. He had an alibi. He had no blood on him. But none of that seemed to matter. As police built their case, another figure stayed quietly in the background: Pam Hupp—Betsy’s friend, the last person to see her alive, and the unexpected beneficiary of her life insurance policy. In this episode, we follow the case from wrongful conviction to the slow unraveling of a story that was never as simple as it first seemed.
--------
52:55
We Digress: Musings with a Medium
We say it all the time—so now it’s a series. “We Digress” is true crime adjacent: strange stories, interviews, and the stuff that doesn’t fit neatly into a regular episode.There are people who say they can communicate with the dead—not as a trick or a party game, but as a calling. They call themselves mediums. To some, it’s a sacred gift. To others, it’s hard to believe. Join us for a special episode of GRIMM where we sit down and pick the brain of psychic medium, Julia Jette.
--------
1:31:34
Episode 98: Joe Metheny
Joseph Metheny, a six foot, 500 pound man nicknamed “Tiny” claimed to have killed 10+ people in Baltimore, Maryland. He has become infamous for more than just the lives he allegedly claimed. According to Joe, he served up BBQ human meat at a roadside stand. Was Joe as savage a killer as he said? Or were his tales as tall as him?
--------
1:01:05
Episode 97: Emily Lambert
When 30-year-old Emily Lambert vanished during a weekend trip to New Mexico in March 2014, her friends and family were left desperate for answers. What began as a fun getaway soon spiraled into a chilling mystery involving inconsistent stories, hidden motives, and a shocking confession. In this episode, we retrace Emily’s final hours, examine the investigation that followed, and uncover the disturbing truth behind her tragic fate.
--------
52:03
Trailer- Patreon Bonus Episode 30- The McStay Family Murders
Looking for more GRIMM? Subscribe to our Patreon to unlock additional bonus content, including Patreon Bonus Episode 30, where Laura delves into the disappearance of the McStay family from their home in California in 2010.
Two best friends retell stories about murders, mysteries, and all the spine chilling things in between. Expect laughter, tears, and some chills along the way.