Being Human

Scrupulosity often looks like devotion — but when fear takes over, even our spiritual life can become consumed by doubt, checking, and the search for certainty. In this episode, Dr. Greg Bottaro continues the series on OCPD and perfectionism, exploring the difference between a healthy conscience and a scrupulous one, why mercy can be hard to trust, and how our experiences shape the way we see God. Holiness was never meant to be an endless audit — it was meant to lead us into relationship with the One who loves us.

Key Topics:
How reciting the truth about mercy in your head does nothing to change what your body still believes
Why certainty about being forgiven is the one thing this pattern can never actually get
Why confession, meant to bring peace, can quietly become just another form of checking
How the voice you call your conscience might actually be a punishing voice in disguise
Why the face you're afraid God is making at you was never really His
How the saints wrestled with scrupulosity — and what finally brought them peace wasn't more proof
Why doing this work alone almost always makes the pattern worse
How the way out can feel too easy to trust
Learn More:
Previous episodes in this series on Obsessive Compulsive Personality Patterns: Ep. #290: "I'm Only Loved When I'm Perfect": The Lie Fueling Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder
Ep. #291: OCPD and Scrupulosity: How the Worship of Rules and Control Leads to the Loneliness of Certainty

Episode referenced on spiritual bypassing: Why "Everything Happens for a Reason" Isn't Working: The Holy Words We Use to Avoid Healing
Join us at the Summit of Integration this October in Dallas — launching the Year of St. John Paul II
Start of the Being Human series on the Antisocial Defense Patterns: Ep. #281: Control or Be Controlled: The Devastating Wounds Behind Antisocial Behavioral Patterns

Start of the Being Human series on the Borderline Defense Patterns: Ep. #269: BORDERLINE: The Push-Pull Between a Fear of Abandonment and Annihilation

Start of the Being Human series on the Histrionic Defense Patterns: Ep. #274: To Be Loved Is to Perform: Inside the Histrionic Compulsion for Attention and Validation

Start of the Being Human series on the Dependent Defense Patterns: Ep. #265: Jerry Maguire, Gollum, and the Fear of Not Existing

Start of the Being Human series on the Narcissistic Defense Patterns: Ep. #261: Narcissism and the Terror of Being Ordinary

Need help? Schedule a free CatholicPsych consultation.
Want to help? Learn more about our Certification in Professional Accompaniment.
Follow Us on Socials: Instagram | Facebook | YouTube | Twitter (X) | LinkedIn

Certainty feels like safety. But you can only ever be certain alone — and the life you build on control slowly becomes a lonely one.
In week two of the series on OCPD, Dr. Greg explores why we reach for control when trust feels dangerous — and how the certainty we build to feel safe ends up costing us the very relationships it was meant to protect.
Key Topics:
Why the certainty that makes you feel safe is the same thing that leaves you alone
How a rule can feel safer than a person — because a rule never changes its face
Why the control you use to protect the people you love can drive them straight into the danger you feared
How devotion can quietly turn into a contract with God instead of trust in Him
Why trying harder to get it perfect is the pattern itself, not the way out of it
Learn More:
Previous episode in this series — OCPD Part 1: Ep. #290: "I'm Only Loved When I'm Perfect": The Lie Fueling Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder

Join us at the Summit of Integration this October in Dallas — launching the Year of St. John Paul II
Faith of the Fatherless: The Psychology of Atheism by Dr. Paul Vitz — on how wounded trust in a father can shape our capacity for faith
Person and Act — St. John Paul II's (Karol Wojtyła's) philosophical work on the acting person, and the personalist heart of this episode
Stop Walking on Eggshells by Paul Mason & Randi Kreger — the book on borderline patterns Dr. Greg references
Start of the Being Human series on the Antisocial Defense Patterns: Ep. #281: Control or Be Controlled: The Devastating Wounds Behind Antisocial Behavioral Patterns

Start of the Being Human series on the Borderline Defense Patterns: Ep. #269: BORDERLINE: The Push-Pull Between a Fear of Abandonment and Annihilation

Start of the Being Human series on the Histrionic Defense Patterns: Ep. #274: To Be Loved Is to Perform: Inside the Histrionic Compulsion for Attention and Validation

Start of the Being Human series on the Dependent Defense Patterns: Ep. #265: Jerry Maguire, Gollum, and the Fear of Not Existing

Start of the Being Human series on the Narcissistic Defense Patterns: Ep. #261: Narcissism and the Terror of Being Ordinary

Need help? Schedule a free CatholicPsych consultation.
Want to help? Learn more about our Certification in Professional Accompaniment.
Follow Us on Socials: Instagram | Facebook | YouTube | Twitter (X) | LinkedIn

Perfectionism doesn't always come from loving excellence. Sometimes it's the only way you've ever known how to feel safe.
In the first episode of a new series on Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder, Dr. Greg unpacks how perfectionism, rigidity, and control take root—and why, underneath them, control quietly fills the space where trust was supposed to be.
Key Topics:
Why the pursuit of perfection is often less about loving excellence and more about not feeling safe without it
How "until I'm perfect, I'm not loved" becomes the sentence an entire personality gets built on
Why one small mistake can feel like disconnection instead of just a mistake
How conscientiousness and perfectionism can look identical from the outside—and the one thing that tells them apart
Why you can get everything right and still never feel free to rest
Why the love you keep trying to earn was already given—before you got anything right
Learn More:
Person and Act and Related Essays by Karol Wojtyła (St. John Paul II) — the anthropology of self-possession and self-gift behind this episode
Join a future Black Elk healing retreat at the Hawkeye Ranch in Wyoming
Episode referenced on spiritual bypassing and scrupulosity: Ep. #288: Why "Everything Happens for a Reason" Isn't Working: The Holy Words We Use to Avoid Healing

Inner Parts Easy Conversation Guide — an audio guide to get to know your inner parts.
Start of the Being Human series on the Antisocial Defense Patterns: Ep. #281: Control or Be Controlled: The Devastating Wounds Behind Antisocial Behavioral Patterns

Start of the Being Human series on the Borderline Defense Patterns: Ep. #269: BORDERLINE: The Push-Pull Between a Fear of Abandonment and Annihilation

Start of the Being Human series on the Histrionic Defense Patterns: Ep. #274: To Be Loved Is to Perform: Inside the Histrionic Compulsion for Attention and Validation

Start of the Being Human series on the Dependent Defense Patterns: Ep. #265: Jerry Maguire, Gollum, and the Fear of Not Existing

Start of the Being Human series on the Narcissistic Defense Patterns: Ep. #261: Narcissism and the Terror of Being Ordinary

Need help? Schedule a free CatholicPsych consultation
Want to help? Learn more about our Certification in Professional Accompaniment
Follow Us on Socials: Instagram | Facebook | YouTube | Twitter (X) | LinkedIn

Avoidance works. That's the problem. Every time you dodge the hard thing, the relief is real—and so is the price you don't see coming.
In this final episode of the series on avoidance, Dr. Greg makes the case that the way out isn't escape or a burst of willpower, but presence: staying in the room one second longer than you want to, and letting God meet you in the mess you were trying to hide.
Key Topics:
Why the relief avoidance gives you is exactly what keeps you stuck
Why good therapy and mentorship refuse to hand you advice—and why that's what actually heals
How even "staying present" can quietly become one more way to avoid what's surfacing
Why healing works like a bruise, not a breakthrough—slow, at its own pace, and impossible to rush
What to do the moment the wall goes up: stay in the room one second longer than you want to
Why God doesn't wait at the finish line of your healing, but walks through the locked door to meet you in it
Learn More:
Presence Virtual Retreat: As a gift to listeners of Being Human, we're offering two full months free. Use code BHVRTRIAL at checkout to begin. The Retreat is a monthly subscription that brings together faith and psychology to help you overcome anxiety, quiet negative thought patterns, and live as if you truly believe in a God who loves you. Your first two months are completely free; after that, it continues at $17/month, and you're free to cancel anytime. 
Stay connected — join our newsletter
Join us at the Summit of Integration this October in Dallas
Watch Being Human on YouTube – Watch the full video archive of the Being Human podcast
Previous episodes in this series on Avoidance: Ep. #286: A Mental Tug of War: Inside the Avoidant Mind and the Burden of Being Known
Ep. #287: We Are Not Robots: Why Connection Is Not Optional for Human Flourishing
Ep. #288: Why "Everything Happens for a Reason" Isn't Working: The Holy Words We Use to Avoid Healing

Start of the Being Human series on the Antisocial Defense Patterns: Ep. #281: Control or Be Controlled: The Devastating Wounds Behind Antisocial Behavioral Patterns

Start of the Being Human series on the Borderline Defense Patterns: Ep. #269: BORDERLINE: The Push-Pull Between a Fear of Abandonment and Annihilation

Start of the Being Human series on the Histrionic Defense Patterns: Ep. #274: To Be Loved Is to Perform: Inside the Histrionic Compulsion for Attention and Validation

Start of the Being Human series on the Dependent Defense Patterns: Ep. #265: Jerry Maguire, Gollum, and the Fear of Not Existing

Start of the Being Human series on the Narcissistic Defense Patterns: Ep. #261: Narcissism and the Terror of Being Ordinary

Previous episodes on parts work (IFS): Ep. #34: A New Theory! w/ a Catholic Lens
Ep. #35: Why Do I Feel Like I Have Conflicting Thoughts? w/ Dr. Peter Malinoski

Need help? Schedule a free CatholicPsych consultation
Want to help? Learn more about our Certification in Professional Accompaniment
Follow Us on Socials: Instagram | Facebook | YouTube | Twitter (X) | LinkedIn

"Offer it up." "I've forgiven them." "Everything happens for a reason." Every one of them is true—and every one can become a way to avoid the healing God is actually offering.
In this episode, Dr. Greg names spiritual bypassing: using prayer, devotion, and even good theology to step around grief, anger, and the wounds still waiting underneath. He explains why grace builds on nature, and why God heals only the humanity we're willing to bring into the light.
Key Topics:
Why the one escape nobody warns you about is the one everyone applauds: prayer, retreats, "offering it up"
How "I've already forgiven them" can be completely true and still leave the same wound bleeding for years
Why "I'm still discerning" is sometimes just stalling with a halo on it
How taking Mary or Joseph as your parent can heal a wound—or quietly become the reason you never grieve the one you actually had
Why the anger you keep spiritualizing away might be the exact thing you most need to listen to
Why you can pray for years, go to confession after confession, and still land in the same cycle—and what that finally reveals
Learn More:
Stay connected — join our newsletter
Join us at the Summit of Integration this October in Dallas
Online presentation on anxiety: Learn the "secret" Dr. Greg holds back in this episode—that the anxiety itself isn't the problem 
Presence Virtual Retreat: Practice the presence of God and trustful surrender 
Integrated Life app: Bring every part of yourself into the light—JP2's meaning of integration 
State of the Institute replay: Hear the massive "Year of JP2" news
The Personalist Cure: Dr. Greg's book on John Paul II's philosophy and its role in psychology
Person and Act: St. John Paul II's (Karol Wojtyła's) philosophical work on integration and the acting person, referenced in this episode
Our God's Brother: St. John Paul II's (Karol Wojtyła's) play about Brother Albert 
Previous episodes in this series on Avoidance: Ep. #286: A Mental Tug of War: Inside the Avoidant Mind and the Burden of Being Known
Ep. #287: We Are Not Robots: Why Connection Is Not Optional for Human Flourishing

Start of the Being Human series on the Antisocial Defense Patterns: Ep. #281: Control or Be Controlled: The Devastating Wounds Behind Antisocial Behavioral Patterns

Start of the Being Human series on the Histrionic Defense Patterns: Ep. #274: To Be Loved Is to Perform: Inside the Histrionic Compulsion for Attention and Validation

Start of the Being Human series on the Borderline Defense Patterns: Ep. #269: BORDERLINE: The Push-Pull Between a Fear of Abandonment and Annihilation

Start of the Being Human series on the Dependent Defense Patterns: Ep. #265: Jerry Maguire, Gollum, and the Fear of Not Existing

Start of the Being Human series on the Narcissistic Defense Patterns: Ep. #261: Narcissism and the Terror of Being Ordinary

Previous episodes on parts work (IFS): Ep. #34: A New Theory! w/ a Catholic Lens
Ep. #35: Why Do I Feel Like I Have Conflicting Thoughts? w/ Dr. Peter Malinoski

Need help? Schedule a free CatholicPsych consultation
Want to help? Learn more about our Certification in Professional Accompaniment
Follow Us on Socials: Instagram | Facebook | YouTube | Twitter (X) | LinkedIn