Sports Cards Live

Jeremy Lee is joined by David Chase, Jeremy “Texas Snowman” Donson, and Joe Poirot as the conversation takes a more philosophical turn before Chris McGill and Josh Adams join the panel. What starts as a continuation of the value discussion quickly evolves into a much deeper debate around how collectors should actually think about cards. Chris introduces a sharp perspective that flips the typical approach, arguing that value should be the result of understanding a card, not the starting point. That idea opens the door to a broader conversation about what it really means to be an advanced collector. Is it about budget, experience, or something else entirely? The group explores the importance of research, context, and understanding the full landscape of a player or set before making decisions, while also acknowledging that not every collector is at that stage. Along the way, concepts like “own appeal,” long-term holding, and the role of value as both a tool and a distraction are unpacked through multiple lenses. This is one of those segments where the hobby gets broken down at a higher level and forces you to reconsider how you approach collecting.

Subscribe to Sports Cards Live on YouTube and your favorite podcast platform, and if you enjoy the content, please leave a rating and review. Pick up a copy of POPs & COMPs: Truths, Insights & Psychology into the Numbers that Drive the Sports Card Market on Amazon. Explore the Hobby Spectrum and discover your collector profile at sportscardslive.com. And as always, thank you for being part of the community.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Jeremy Lee continues with David Chase and Jeremy “Texas Snowman” Donson of Collector Investor Auctions as the conversation moves beyond surface-level takes and into how collectors actually behave in real situations. Reacting to audience comments, the group challenges the idea that collectors can fully separate enjoyment from value, especially when meaningful dollars are involved. Jeremy Donson shares personal collecting experiences that highlight how relationships, timing, and backstory can become part of the card itself, adding a layer of meaning that goes beyond comps. The discussion also touches on how collectors justify purchases, how memory and attachment play into decision-making, and how the line between emotional and financial value is often much blurrier than people admit. This segment brings the collector mindset into focus in a way that feels real, not theoretical.

Subscribe to Sports Cards Live on YouTube and your favorite podcast platform, and if you enjoy the content, please leave a rating and review. Pick up a copy of POPs & COMPs: Truths, Insights & Psychology into the Numbers that Drive the Sports Card Market on Amazon. Explore the Hobby Spectrum and discover your collector profile at thehobbyspectrum.com. And as always, thank you for being part of the community.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Jeremy Lee is joined by David Chase to kick off the show, before welcoming Jeremy “Texas Snowman” Donson of Collector Investor Auctions. The episode begins with Jeremy sharing his experience traveling to New York City to broadcast live from the Fanatics Collect studio, offering a behind-the-scenes look at what it was like operating in a completely different environment and how the show evolved in that setting. The conversation then shifts into one of the hobby’s more polarizing topics right now… value. Is talking about card value a problem? Why does it trigger some collectors? And where should the balance really be between passion and price? With perspectives from both collector and dealer lenses, the discussion explores how different mindsets shape the way we buy, hold, and think about our cards, while also touching on auction dynamics, buying behavior, and the role value plays across the spectrum.

Subscribe to Sports Cards Live on YouTube and your favorite podcast platform, and if you enjoy the content, please leave a rating and review. Check out POPs & COMPs for deeper insights into the numbers and psychology driving the hobby. Explore your collecting identity with the Collector Investor Spectrum and see where you fall within the hobby. And as always, thank you for being part of the community.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

In this episode, Jeremy Lee closes out Episode 305 with Joey Elmasri, David Chase, and Josh Adams by digging deeper into one of the biggest underlying questions in the hobby: what happens if card values take a major hit?

The conversation explores how each collector might respond to a serious market drop, whether that would actually change their approach, and why unrealized losses only matter if you decide to sell. From there, the discussion expands into nostalgia, long term collecting behavior, and the difference between buying cards for value versus buying them for meaning, memory, and the simple joy of the chase.

The group also talks about kids in the hobby, father and son collecting, the role nostalgia may play for today’s younger participants down the road, and whether the next generation will eventually become true long term collectors. Along the way, the conversation touches on junk wax parallels, hobby cycles, modern overproduction, and the ongoing tension between hype, flipping, and real collecting.

The episode closes on a fun but honest discussion about whether sports cards are actually cool, or whether collectors are just comfortable being cardboard nerds. It is a fitting ending to a wide ranging conversation about identity, passion, and what keeps people in the hobby beyond prices and headlines.

If you enjoy hobby conversations that mix market reality, nostalgia, and collector perspective, please follow the podcast, leave a rating or review, and share this episode with a fellow collector. You can also check out Jeremy’s new book Pops and Comps and take the Hobby Spectrum assessment to discover your collector identity and connect with other hobbyists in the directory.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

In this episode, Jeremy Lee continues the conversation with Joey from Hoops Hobby Hangout, David Chase, and Josh Adams for a deeper discussion about what today’s hobby is becoming and where it may be headed next.

The episode begins with Joey sharing how Hoops Hobby Hangout came together, from early Instagram relationships and shared basketball card interests to building a group focused more on the cards than clout, value chasing, or social media status. It is a thoughtful look at how smaller hobby communities form and why collector-first spaces still matter.

From there, the conversation opens up into a bigger debate around the changing nature of collecting itself. Are today’s new entrants into the hobby mostly collectors, or are many of them entering through the lens of flipping, growth potential, and short term profit? The group explores how social media, breakers, card shows, and content culture have changed the way younger collectors view cards, and whether the hobby is doing enough to create real long term collectors instead of just feeding a cycle of quick transactions.

Jeremy, David, Josh, and Joey also dig into what happens if the market cools in a major way. Would a big drop in card values hurt the hobby, or would true collectors simply keep collecting and see it as an opportunity? It is a wide ranging conversation about hobby cycles, risk tolerance, collector psychology, and the difference between owning cards because you love them versus owning them because you hope someone else will pay more later.

If you enjoy hobby conversations that go beyond the surface and wrestle with where collecting is really headed, please follow the podcast, leave a rating or review, and share this episode with a fellow collector. You can also check out Jeremy’s new book Pops and Comps and take the Hobby Spectrum assessment to discover your collector identity and connect with other hobbyists in the directory.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices