Sports Cards Live

The discussion takes a philosophical turn as Chris McGill introduces a framework comparing sports card collectors to both stock market investors and art collectors.

Inspired by visits to the Chicago Art Institute and the Milwaukee Art Museum, Chris explores how collectors assign meaning, value, and significance to the items they pursue. The result is one of the most thought-provoking conversations of the evening.

Topics include:

• Buying cards like an investor versus buying cards like an art collector• Personal significance versus financial significance• Why some cards become lifelong companions• Identity, self-expression, and collecting• The role of nostalgia, symbolism, and memory• Liquidity, opportunity cost, and investment thinking• Why specific copies matter more than many collectors realize• Eye appeal, provenance, uniqueness, and story• The emotional side of collecting• How major acquisitions reshape a collection

The panel examines the motivations behind collecting and asks a fundamental question: are we building portfolios, curating collections, or doing a little bit of both?

Featuring Jeremy Lee, Chris McGill, David Novak, Joshua Adams, Joe Poirot, and David Chase.

Links & Resources

• The Hobby Spectrum: https://thehobbyspectrum.com• Pops & Comps on Amazon• Fanatics Collect Affiliate Link

• Share this episode with a fellow collector

Sports cards is a lifestyle.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The panel expands as Chris McGill and Joshua Adams join the conversation, leading to a fascinating discussion about late-90s football cards, hobby growth, collecting philosophy, and what truly makes a card significant.

David Novak explains why he believes 1997 and 1998 football represent some of the most overlooked collecting opportunities in the hobby, while Chris McGill dives deep into the rarity, innovation, and appeal of the era's greatest inserts and parallels.

The conversation also turns toward the future of the hobby, Fanatics' influence on collecting, and whether today's hobby growth is creating more collectors or more gamblers.

Topics include:

• Why 1997-98 football may be undervalued• PMGs, Masterpieces, Quantum Golds, Legacy Showcase 1/1s, and other hobby icons• The relationship between sports popularity and card values• Michael Rubin, Fanatics, and hobby growth• Collectors versus gamblers in today's hobby• How social media impacts collecting behavior• What defines a "big card" or a "grail card"• Why hobby knowledge often matters more than hobby budget• The role of rarity, significance, and personal meaning in collecting

Plus, the panel debates some of the hobby's biggest questions while the Sports Cards Live chat delivers plenty of strong opinions along the way.

Links & Resources

• The Hobby Spectrum: https://thehobbyspectrum.com• Pops & Comps on Amazon• Fanatics Collect Affiliate Link

• Share this episode with a fellow collector

Sports cards is a lifestyle.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The conversation gets deeper as David Novak joins Jeremy Lee and David Chase for a spirited discussion about sports cards as investments, generational attitudes toward risk, and whether collectors should view cardboard as part of a broader financial strategy.

David shares his perspective on why some millennials are more willing to take calculated risks with their investment portfolios, sparking an engaging debate on retirement accounts, diversification, risk tolerance, and the role sports cards can play alongside traditional investments.

Topics include:

• Are sports cards legitimate investments?• Millennials and risk-taking behavior• Using hobby knowledge as an investment advantage• 401(k)s, retirement planning, and alternative assets• Why some collectors prefer blue-chip cards over prospecting• Vintage versus ultra-modern investing• The dangers of chasing hype• Mahomes, Ohtani, Trout, Judge, LeBron, Crosby, and long-term collectability• Bubbles within the hobby market• Why experience and time horizon matter

Jeremy, David Novak, and David Chase bring different perspectives to one of the hobby's most debated topics: whether sports cards belong in an investment portfolio and, if so, how.

Links & Resources

• The Hobby Spectrum: https://thehobbyspectrum.com
• Pops & Comps on Amazon
• Fanatics Collect Affiliate Link

• Share this episode with a fellow collector

Sports cards is a lifestyle.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Jeremy Lee and Joe Poirot welcome David Novak of Upstate Sports Cards to Sports Cards Live for a deep discussion on collecting philosophy, consolidation, and the mindset of today's hobbyist.

David shares his journey from collecting everything from ultra-modern stars to vintage icons before ultimately narrowing his collection down to just a handful of cornerstone cards. The conversation explores whether millennial collectors are increasingly prioritizing quality over quantity and what drives the desire to own fewer, more significant pieces.

Topics include:

• The rise of collection consolidation• The psychology of the modern collector• The Pareto Principle and card collecting• Why some collectors are moving toward elite, centerpiece cards• PMGs, Masterpieces, and hobby tier lists• Football card market opportunities• Dallas Cowboys collecting and hobby nostalgia• Whether collector preferences shape long-term card values• The role of competition, status, and personal fulfillment in collecting

Plus, Jeremy, Joe, and David debate football cards, hobby trends, and what truly makes a card significant.

Links & Resources

• The Hobby Spectrum: https://thehobbyspectrum.com• Pops & Comps on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/POPS-COMPS-Insights-Psychology-Numbers/dp/1069808903• Follow Jeremy on Fanatics Collect: Fanatics Collect Affiliate Link

• Share this episode with a fellow collector

Sports cards are a lifestyle.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Jeremy Lee and Joe Poirot kick off Episode 317 of Sports Cards Live with a look at several major developments happening across the hobby.

Jeremy shares details on his new exclusive Fanatics Collect Originals series, The Hunt, including what viewers can expect from the live interactive format and why this next chapter is such an exciting opportunity.

The conversation then shifts to Enter the Inferno, the new hobby technology pitch competition debuting live on the National Sports Collectors Convention main stage. Jeremy discusses the inspiration behind the event, the judging panel, and what hobby entrepreneurs can expect.

The guys also talk about:

• The upcoming National Sports Collectors Convention
• Joe's first-ever National appearance
• Hobby Spectrum developments and discoverability features
• Jeremy's latest vintage memorabilia acquisitions, including a Joe DiMaggio game-used piece and a rare Ty Cobb pickup
• Golden Auctions highlights, Cracker Jack cards, and vintage market observations
• Fanatics Collect, content creation, and the evolving hobby media landscape

Plus, plenty of interaction with the Sports Cards Live community throughout the show.

Please support the show:

Subscribe to Sports Cards Live on YouTube

Follow Sports Cards Live on Fanatics Collect

https://fanaticscollect.onelink.me/xx0N/iyiniif4

Follow Sports Cards Live on Instagram @jlee_sportscardslive
Visit The Hobby Spectrum and complete your collector profile hobbyspectrum.com
Share this episode with a fellow collector
Sports cards is a lifestyle.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices